Short Circuit 339 | The Crime of Journalism

Short Circuit

Part of the job description of a journalist is talk to public officials, gather information, and report on it. Unfortunately, that seems to be a crime in Texas. An unconstitutional crime, to be sure, but enough of a crime that the Fifth Circuit said there was qualified immunity for officers who arrested a citizen journalist for asking question of a source within a police department and reporting what she heard. JT Morris of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) joins us to discuss this loooooong running case and a pending cert petition at the Supreme Court. It involves the First Amendment, freedom of the press, the Fourth Amendment, arrest warrants, retaliation, and all kinds of Fifth Circuit drama. Then we move to the Eleventh Circuit where our own Anya Bidwell reports on an extremely strict version of qualified immunity that protected a forcible strip search made of a visitor to a prison without any probable cause. There are also concurrences disagreeing with the circuit’s own caselaw, including and one of our favorite staples: a Judge Newsom concurrence asking “what is the law?”

IJ event with the Texas Observer in Austin on September 4!

Short Circuit on YouTube

Villarreal v. Laredo (en banc)

Villarreal v. Laredo (panel)

Villarreal cert petition

Short Circuit 201 (discussing Villarreal panel opinion w/o dissent)

Pentagon Papers case

Gilmore v. Georgia Dept. of Corrections